The Carpenters Story Reviews

Tribute ActsConcerts

Average customer review: 1.5 star rating (1.5 Stars)

Number of reviews: 10



3.0 star rating Bronwen Smewing from London, England


The show doesn’t tell the story in any depth, shows video clips (out of sync) the main singer, I’m afraid, sounded like a karaoke attempt, didn’t do Karen’s voice any justice of her incredible voice. This should really be billed as a tribute not their ‘story’

2.0 star rating Tracey from London, England


I saw the show last night and was very disappointed as there was very little content on the actual story of the carpenters. The show was more of a singalong with a few video clips in the background. I would say if you want the carpenters story you would be better off watching a documentary which I think has been on the tv before. Although the lead singer had a good voice it didn’t do justice to Karen’s velvet tones. This to me was like watching a tribute band that didn’t look or sound like the carpenters.

2.0 star rating Jill from Liverpool,


There was no carpenters story. The show was more like a tribute band .

2.0 star rating Lisa from London, England


We saw the show last night and was that disappointed that we left at the interval. The lead singer struggled with a lot notes, and her voice was just not strong enough lacking depth. She sounded nothing like Karen Carpenter, and gave more the impression that we were at a Karaoke sing along. The backing band singers were much better than the lead singer. Really would not recommend this one for Carpenter fans.

1.0 star rating Steven from Plymouth


Saw this in Plymouh last night 02/04/23, but they do not have a review site. Very disappointed. With the word "Story" in the title, was expecting something similar to Beautiful or Jersey Boys. Instead we endured what in my opinion was a misleading and poor show. The musicians were very good, but the format, backdrop and vocalist left much to be desired. as already mentioned by another reviewer the background video was out of sinc. Some of the supposed happenings in 1971 I suggest never happened in 1971and there was very little actual Carpenters story told. Why were the songs not sung in order of release date? like a story is told. We seriously debated leaving at the interval but decided to stay in case it improved in the second half, both of us decided it did not. Very poor evenings entertainment.

1.0 star rating Gina Covington from Brighton,


Only go to see this mimed karaoke act if you want to spend the same price for a FULL production West End show as you would for a bunch of pensioners that you could see for free in a pub! This was the worst show I have ever seen and I have seen a lot. The whole premise is mis-leading. There is no story, only a shoddy screen in the background which doesn't show anything of any relevance just floating masks when the singer does a poor version of masquerade. At one point, I even forgot that the show was supposed to be about the Carpenters as the screen just showed images of the Muppets! Five people left in my row during the interval as this was the Claire Furley show - a woman I would never have paid full ticket price to see. The whole thing was cringe from beginning to end, at one point I felt as if I was sat in a nursery when the muppets starting showing up on the screen and Claire Furley asked if anyone could 'hum' along. The guitarist who must have been in his late seventies thought that he was Jimi Hendrix which was ultra-cringe as he barely had the strength to lift up the guitar yet alone mime playing it. This show is grossly mis-sold to make you listen to a singer you might never choose to see. Please, don't waste your money on this poor, embarrassing farse. It is an insult to Karen Carpenter's memory and in my opinion highly disprespectful. If Richard Carpenter knew that people such as these were exploiting his sister this way to gain publicity, I am sure he would be furious!!!

1.0 star rating Kenny from Liverpool,


Sound from the band was very poor and insipid. Singer didn’t sound anything like Karen Carpenter or even had a good voice. Audience obviously hadn’t a clue what they were listening to, as they were all cheering and gave them a standing ovation???.?.


What you thought

Seen The Carpenters Story? Loved it? Hated it?

Help your fellow London Theatreland visitors by leaving the first review. Everyone will love you for it, we promise!

Write a review now


Venue home

Venue home





Additional Information

seating chart
SeatingSeating map

Spread the word

Sound good to you? Share this page on social media and let your friends know about The Carpenters Story at New Wimbledon Theatre.

Keep up to date

I want email news and updates for events in my area! Read how we protect your data.

Please note: The term New Wimbledon Theatre and/or The Carpenters Story as well as all associated graphics, logos, and/or other trademarks, tradenames or copyrights are the property of the New Wimbledon Theatre and/or The Carpenters Story and are used herein for factual descriptive purposes only. We are in no way associated with or authorized by the New Wimbledon Theatre and/or The Carpenters Story and neither that entity nor any of its affiliates have licensed or endorsed us to sell tickets, goods and or services in conjunction with their events.